Truth and Reconciliation… and Justice

While thinking of reconciliation, the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission came to mind. But, after doing a little reading that case doesn’t seem to apply to this case. The TRC seemed more focused on creating an accurate historical record of past human rights violations and bestowed amnesty rather than absolution.

I’ve read that a common criticism of the TRC from victims was that the amnesty eliminated their chance of attaining justice. “Most felt that justice was a prerequisite for reconciliation rather than an alternative to it.”

That raises an interesting question: how are justice and reconciliation tied together? Is one conditional on the other? Or should they be seen as two separate paths, one secular and legal, one interpersonal and spiritual?

Clearly, the person who tear gassed Edmonds in 1988 would first have to gain enough strength on their internal and spiritual path before they could walk the judicial path that waits.

Discuss your thoughts reconciliation vs. justice.